Why The Ottawa Senators Should Not Trade Brian Elliot
I’m a Bay Area Sharks fan so I’m not well-versed on the Ottawa Senators but I think the team should hold on to Brian Elliot for now and wait until after next season to make a move. Pascal Leclaire is a fragile and injury-prone goalie that will probably miss some time next year. If that happens, Elliot can come up from Binghamton and split time with Auld, who is nothing but a disposable goalie. If Leclaire manages to stay healthy he’ll probably put up good numbers and the Senators can be decently convinced that he’ll turn out to be their goalie of the future.
Obviously, Elliot’s trade stock would be much lower at that time but I think it’s a risk worth taking. Leclaire just hasn’t shown enough consistency to be deemed the savior of the Sens’ net and make Elliot expendable. Few would be talking about Steve Mason if Leclaire had stayed healthy. Granted, he’s played on bad teams but so has Marc Denis who was durable enough to end up on the loss column 102 times during his last three seasons with Columbus. That’s almost as many games Leclaire has played with the same team since he made his debut in 2003.
The only reason Leclaire is regarded so highly is his high draft position – #8 overall in 2001. Oddly, I doubt Senators fan would be as excited if Rick Dipietro (#1 overall, 2000) and his brittle hips and knees showed up with his gear at Scotia Bank Place in Kanata looking for a starting job.
Look, I don’t know Pascal Leclaire and I don’t want him to fail but he just hasn’t done anything to make the Senators comfortable enough to warrant trading away a good goalie who can be great in Elliot. That’s what this longwinded rant is all about.


